A Treat Here, A Treat There... Is It Too Much?
Let’s be honest—treating our pups is one of the best parts of being a dog parent. That little tail wag, the excited eyes—it’s irresistible. But somewhere between “just one” and “okay, five,” a question sneaks in: Are dog treats bad for dogs?
Let’s unpack that together, in simple terms, with a sprinkle of love and logic.
Why This Question Matters More Than You Think
Giving your dog treats isn't bad—but like anything in life, too much of a good thing can lead to trouble. Think of dog treats like snacks for us. Chips and cookies? Amazing. But not dinner, right?
It’s all about balance, knowing what’s inside those treats, and why you're giving them.
What Are Dog Treats, Really?
The Difference Between Treats and Regular Dog Food
Dog food is your pup’s main source of nutrition—treats are the bonus. Regular meals are carefully balanced to give your dog all the protein, fiber, vitamins, and nutrients they need. Treats? Not so much.
Common Ingredients Found in Dog Treats
Some are great—chicken, sweet potatoes, even pumpkin. Others… not so much. We're talking about artificial flavors, preservatives, sugar, and fillers like corn or soy. These can add calories without any real nutritional value.
Types of Dog Treats
Store-Bought Treats
These are convenient but not all created equal. Some are packed with unhealthy fillers and additives.
Natural Treats
Think freeze-dried liver, chicken jerky, or carrot sticks. These are closer to whole foods and usually a safer bet.
Homemade Treats
You control the ingredients, so you know exactly what your dog is munching on. Plus, making treats can be a fun bonding activity.
The Good Side of Treats
Training Made Easy
Treats are magical when it comes to training. A small, tasty bite can be the perfect reward for learning a new trick or mastering recall.
Strengthening the Bond
Treats can be a way to show affection—like giving flowers, but for dogs. Just don’t overdo it.
Mental Stimulation and Enrichment
Stuff a treat inside a puzzle toy, and boom—you’ve got a brain game that keeps your pup engaged and happy.
The Potential Downsides of Dog Treats
Hidden Sugars, Fats, and Fillers
A lot of cheap treats are like junk food. They’re tasty but full of unnecessary calories and sugar that can harm your dog over time.
Obesity in Dogs and the Treat Connection
Over 50% of dogs in the U.S. are overweight—and yes, too many treats are part of the problem. Obesity can shorten a dog’s life and lead to serious health issues.
Allergies and Food Sensitivities
If your dog is scratching more than usual or has tummy troubles, treats could be the culprit—especially if they contain wheat, dairy, or chicken by-products.
Over-Treating and Behavioral Issues
Too many treats can lead to picky eaters or pups who only listen when there’s a snack in sight. Sound familiar?
How Many Treats Are Too Many?
The 10% Rule
Treats should make up no more than 10% of your dog’s daily calories. If you’re unsure, ask your vet or check online dog calorie calculators.
Reading Labels Like a Pro
Avoid anything with unpronounceable ingredients. Look for treats with real, whole-food ingredients at the top of the list.
What to Look for in Healthy Treats
Good Ingredients
Lean meats, veggies, fruits, and grains like oats or rice.
What to Avoid
Artificial colors, preservatives (like BHA or BHT), excess salt, sugar, and anything that sounds like a chemistry experiment.
Trusted Brands
Choose companies with transparent sourcing, limited ingredients, and a good reputation among dog parents and vets alike.
Vet-Approved Treat Tips
Talk to Your Vet
They can recommend treats based on your dog’s age, weight, and health conditions.
Breed-Specific Needs
Some breeds are more prone to weight gain or sensitivities—be extra mindful if you’ve got a pug, lab, or golden.
Are Homemade Treats Better?
Benefits of DIY
Fewer additives, lower cost, and more love baked in.
Easy Recipe
Try this: Mix canned pumpkin, oats, and a spoon of peanut butter (xylitol-free!)—bake at 350°F until firm. Boom. Healthy treats in 30 minutes.
What Dog Parents Often Get Wrong
Loving With Too Many Treats
We give treats out of love—but overdoing it can hurt our pups in the long run.
Wrong Rewards
Using treats to calm an anxious dog or distract from bad behavior might backfire. Treats should reward good actions, not soothe stress.
Training Treats vs. Regular Treats
Size Matters
Training treats should be tiny and low-calorie since you’ll use them often. Regular treats can be a bit more substantial but still healthy.
Purpose First
If the treat isn’t helping your dog learn or connect, it’s just a snack. Make each bite count.
Alternatives to Treats
Praise and Play
Your voice, a belly rub, or a favorite toy can be just as rewarding as food for many dogs.
Safe Human Foods
Tiny bits of apple (no seeds), carrots, green beans, or blueberries can make great occasional treats.
How to Build a Treat Routine That Works
Consistency Is Key
Don’t let treats become a free-for-all. Create structure—use them at the same times, for the same purposes.
Track What You Give
Write it down or keep mental notes. You’d be surprised how fast those little bites add up!
Real Stories From Real Dog Parents
Meet Daisy, the Slimmed-Down Spaniel
Her parents swapped store-bought treats for green beans and started using praise instead of food. She dropped 5 pounds and has way more energy.
Buddy Beat His Allergies
Once his treats were switched to single-ingredient sweet potato chews, the itching stopped. Simple changes = big results.
Conclusion
Treats aren’t bad. But how, why, and what you treat with makes all the difference. When used mindfully, they become powerful tools for love, training, and bonding.
So go ahead—treat your pup. Just do it with purpose. ❤️🐾
FAQs
Can treats replace meals?
Nope! Treats should only be a bonus. Your dog needs balanced meals for full nutrition.
What’s the best treat for sensitive stomachs?
Try boiled chicken, pumpkin, or plain rice crackers with no added salt or flavor.
How often should I give my dog a treat?
Stick to the 10% rule. A few small treats a day is usually plenty.
Are grain-free treats better?
Not always. Unless your dog has a grain allergy, grains like oats and rice can be just fine.
Can I give my dog fruit as a treat?
Yes! Blueberries, bananas, and apple slices (no seeds!) are great in moderation.
Share:
How to Keep Your Dog Mentally Stimulated
Why Is My Dog Barking So Much?